Title
WHERE IN THE WORLD......should I go diving?

 

 
By
Ginger Stark
American River College, Geography 350: Data Acquisition in GIS; Fall 2003


 
Abstract
Diving is a thrilling sport, especially to a new and inexperienced diver, such as myself.  The focus of this project is to choose the location of my first dive as a certified diver.  I compared six diving locations focusing on physical conditions, diving conditions and attractions and also the cost of the trip.  In ArcView I performed a query based on my priorities and did a little more research to arrive at my number one choice.

 

 
Introduction
As a newly certified diver I have an entire world of potential diving sites to explore.  Some breathtakingly beautiful, others adventurous and exciting, even dangerous.  My dilema?  Where to go first.  To help in my decision I researched six of the top dive sites.  I imported a world map into ArcView and added major cities.  Finally, I performed a query to further narrow my choices.

 

 
Background
All of my research was done on the internet.  I visited many travel sites and scuba diving tour sites. 
I found a useful map of water temperature that I've included below.  These were obtained online from  the National Oceanographic Data Center.
 
 
Methods
My first task was to find a map to use as my background.  I chose to use ESRI's shape files, including countries, cities, geo-grid, and latitude/longitude data.

From a list of top 100 dive sites I chose six locations that I wanted to explore further.  For each of these six cities I obtained latitude/longitude information, air temperature, water temperature, minimum and maximum underwater visibility, air/hotel cost and most importantly, diving attractions.  In order to use the attractions in a query I assigned each site an attraction rating, ranging from 1-5.  I then performed a query in ArcView of my most important criteria - air temperature, water temperature and dive attraction score.  Three cities met these criteria - Cozumel, Belize and Little Cayman.  I did a little more research to arrive at my number one site.

This project was a very simple GIS project, but it was not without problems.  One problem was that not all of my six cities were an existing city in the ESRI map that I imported.  I overcame this by inserting a theme event in ArcView based on my cities' latitude and longitude data.

This project was very interesting to me and I learned a lot from it, about diving and about GIS.  But, I might have learned more had I chosen a project that allowed importing of more database files. 

Results
Cozumel is an island off of the east coast of Mexico in the Caribbean Ocean. The average temperature is 79 degrees and the water temperature is 77. Visibility is between 120-160 feet. Cozumel diving attractions include the clarity of the water and abundant variety of marine life. Coral reefs and rock formations that form walls, tunnels and caves add adventure. The cost of air fare and hotel is $2550

Puerto Vallarta is located on the western coast of Mexico in the Pacific Ocean. It is actually in the Bay of Banderas which provides calmer waters. The average temperature is 72 degrees and the water temperature is 75 degrees.   Visibility is 20-30'.  Diving attractions include El Morro Island which lies beyond the Bay where larger sea life can often be found, including whales, sharks, mantas, dolphins and sailfish. The terrain consists of a series of pinnacles that rise from the ocean floor creating caves and tunnels. There are several other islands that are good diving locations. These include the Marietas Islands and Los Arcos. The cost of air fare and hotel is $1424.

Belize is located in the Caribbean. It has an estimated population of 200,000.  The average air temperature is 78 degrees and the water temperature is 80. Visibility is often 100 feet ore more. The main diving attraction is the barrier reef  (the second largest in the world) which is over 185 miles long. Another main attraction is the famous Blue Hole, which is part of the lighthouse reef system. It is an almost perfect circular hole ½ mile across and 480’ deep. The cost of air fare and hotel is $2128

Little Cayman- The Cayman Islands lie in the center of the Caribbean and are actually the tips of an undersea mountain. The average air temperature is 82 degrees and the water temperature is 80 degrees. Visibility averages 100 feet and peaks in the summer at 200 feet. The attractions include vertical walls. The most popular being the Bloody Bay Wall, named after a pirate battle, which drops off at 25’ and forms a cliff that extends 6000’ deep! Another attraction is Stingray City which is 12’ deep water where stingrays have become fairly tame. They came to gather in that location because fisherman used the location to clean their catch and the scavenger stingrays would come to feed on the scraps. The cost of air fare and hotel is $2074.

Wailea Bay, Hawaii is located in the Pacific Ocean on the island of Maui. The air temperature averages 85 degrees and the water temperature is 74. Visibility is around 70’. Dive attractions include an abundance of large sea life including sharks, turtles, seals, dolphins and humpback whales. The cost of air fare and hotel is $1901.

 

 Truk Lagoon, Micronesia is a site that is the final resting place for 70 Japanese ships and aircraft that were attacked in WWII. The wrecks are covered in coral and can provide endless hours (days, months…) of exploration. The air temperature averages 82 degrees and the lagoon water temperature averages 84 degrees. The visibility is 60’. The diving attraction obviously is the wrecks. The cost of air fare and hotel is $2790 (which includes 6 days of diving).

Analysis
The query I performed in ArcView consisted of the following:

Air Temperature >= 75 and Water Temperature >=77 and Attraction >=4

Below is the screen display showing the 3 cities (highlighted in yellow) that met that criteria.  Those cities are Cozumel, Belize and Little Cayman Island.  Belize and Little Cayman had a diving attraction score of 5 so I narrowed my choice to those two. 

 

 
Conclusions
And the winner is......BELIZE! I chose Belize because the diving attractions sounded interesting and very exciting!

 

 
References
www.webapps.getty.edu\vow\ (lattitude/longitude)
www.worldclimate.com (weather)
wwwnodc.noaa.gov (water temperature)
www.hsdivers.com (Cozumel)
www.ambergriscaye.com (Belize)
www.caribbeanmag.com (Belize, Little Cayman)
www.chicos-diveshop.com (Puerto Vallarta)
www.atlantisscubaadventures.com (Maui)
www.thorfinn.net (Truk Lagoon)
www.aspzone.com (Maui photo)
www.scubadivingbelize.com (Belize photo)
www.mantaray.com (Cozumel photo)
www.bocadivers.com (Puerto Vallarta photo)
www.diveatlas.com (Belize photo)
www.cayman.com (Little Cayman photo)
ESRI - World Map, Cities Map (shape files)