The attitudes of some doctors may be to blame
|
Elderly women are still being denied potentially
life-saving surgery for breast cancer because of their age.
The claims will be made by senior doctors and other leading
experts at a conference in London on Wednesday.
They come two years after ministers published a national
service framework for older people and pledged to stamp out
age discrimination in the NHS.
However, experts say the problem still exists and in many
cases is resulting in women dying needlessly.
The conference is being organized by the charities Cancer
Research UK and Help the Aged to highlight the problem of age
discrimination in breast cancer care.
'Too old'
It will hear that women over the age of 70 are most likely
to miss out on surgery, largely because doctors believe they
are too old to have an operation.
"There is a myth that women over 70 will not live long
because they are too frail," said Ian Fentiman, professor
of oncology at Guy's and St Thomas's Medical School in London.
 |
"There is a myth that women over 70 will
not live long because they are too frail,
|
"There is a deeply entrenched age bias. We still make
decisions on age alone. The first thing a doctor asks a
patient is how old they are."
According to Professor Fentiman, many of these women are
given the breast cancer drug Tamoxifen instead of surgery.
Studies have suggested that women with breast cancer who
are given Tamoxifen without also having surgery are less
likely to survive than those who have both.
He said the situation is compounded by the fact that many
elderly women do not realize they have a higher risk of
developing breast cancer compared to other women.
"Opinion polls have found that 60% of women over the
age of 70 believe they have no risk or are at a reduced risk
of developing breast cancer," he told BBC News Online.
"However, age is a major risk factor for the
development of most cancers and certainly for breast cancer.
This means that 50% of breast cancers occur in women over the
age of 65 and 60% of deaths from breast cancer occur in that
age group."
Professor Fentiman said this message was not getting
through to older women.
"We as a profession have some blame. We may not have
informed people well enough."
He said women over 70 should be offered the same treatment
as all other women with breast cancer.
"How we treat older people is a test of our civilization,"
he said.
Doctors' attitudes
Dr Richard Sullivan, head of clinical programs at Cancer
Research UK, said changing the attitude of doctors is key to
ensuring elderly women get the care they need.
"Women over 70 are not getting the best treatment they
should be getting for a variety of reasons," he told BBC
News Online.
"One of these is because of the attitude of the
medical profession to treating women over 70. This is
something we need to change.
"We need to get doctors to offer standard treatment to
all women. It is really important that they take biology
rather than chronology into account. Some women of 70 are very
fit."
The Department of Health said more elderly women have had
surgery for breast cancer since its national service framework
was published two years ago.
"The Older People's National Service Framework sets
out our commitment to address age discrimination and provide
treatment and care on the basis of clinical need, and not
age," said a spokeswoman.
"This applies to the treatment of breast cancer and
since the framework's publication in March 2001 significant
progress has been made.
"For example between 2000 and 2002 breast cancer
surgery for patients aged 85 and over rose by 13%."